• 歐洲之聲發刊詞 Eng
  • 關於我們 About us
  • 隱私條款 Privacy Policy
  • 提供新聞 Authors contributions
  • 連絡我們 Contact us
歐洲之聲 Sino Euro Voices
  • 首頁
  • 關注熱點

    媒體人的良知與謊言(附楊繼繩書面答謝詞)

    北京五中全會「老虎成群」

    投資德國峰會斬逾2250億歐元承諾 梅爾茨以「可靠的」德國人形象招商

    歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

    21世紀的「法國大革命」

    上一個 下一個
  • 政經論壇

    北京五中全會「老虎成群」

    歐洲議會的堅決裁決:對中國種族滅絕與侵略政策的重創

    投資德國峰會斬逾2250億歐元承諾 梅爾茨以「可靠的」德國人形象招商

    MAGA文化戰爭正在自我毀滅 就讓共和黨自掘墳墓

    台灣是德國提升經濟韌性不可或缺的夥伴

    上一個 下一個
  • 人權觀察

    判它們一分鐘徒刑——光華社國殤紀念活動之超自然餘緒

    中國民主黨幹部學院將在倫敦啟動——首屆幹部培訓班同步舉行

    歐洲議會的堅決裁決:對中國種族滅絕與侵略政策的重創

    高瑜:丙午赤馬重陽節

    美國擬公開直播槍決爭議:民主法治與人權文明的倒退?

    上一個 下一個
  • 人文天下

    媒體人的良知與謊言(附楊繼繩書面答謝詞)

    老鬼新著《血的黎明》

    【老陳時評】假如老萬一直領導民運

    歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

    21世紀的「法國大革命」

    上一個 下一個
  • 歐洲風情

    【老陳時評】巴塞羅那的獨立紀念碑與西藏獨立運動

    再見,巴塞羅那!

    歐洲民主防護盾 為何與如何打造

    巴黎開業首日 Shein深陷輿論風暴

    展示向日葵的土地:艾未未深入「戰爭腹地」拍攝關於烏克蘭的電影

    上一個 下一個
  • 文學世界

    老鬼新著《血的黎明》

    2026年諾貝爾文學獎得主 安妮·卡森於2013年出版的《Red Doc>》

    台裔德國作家廖樂薇: 用文學展現台灣民主韌性

    Anne Carson wins Nobel prize in literature 2026安妮卡森榮獲2026年諾貝爾文學獎

    當文學遇上審查:高行健、劉曉波與莫言

    上一個 下一個
  • 視頻薈萃

    首屆劉曉波人權獎頒獎典禮

    聖尼古拉教堂:和平祈禱與自由精神的象徵

    《法蘭克福彙報》:歐洲向中國靠近

    CHINA UND WIR · Ein riskantes Spiel

    為信仰與理想奮鬥一生——劉曉波逝世 8 周年紀念會

    上一個 下一個
  • 專文
    • 田牧新著
    • 淇園漫步
    • 田牧筆談
    • 老陳時評
    • 胡平論政
    • 香江寄語
    • 北京觀察
    • 比爾曼自傳
    • 潤南文苑
    • 雪山下的火焰
    • 嚴家祺新著
    • 嚴家祺新著
    • 老魏論天下
    • 六四專欄
    • 追思萬潤南
    • 民運交流
    • 文革60週年
    • AI科技
    • 陽光法案
  • 古典音樂

    精選舒伯特鋼琴古典音樂Ⅱ

    約翰斯特勞斯「春之聲」圓舞曲

    維瓦地古典音樂精選

    孟德爾松古典音樂

    布拉姆斯古典音樂精選

    上一個 下一個
  • English

    A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

    中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era

    始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話

    魏京生基金會第二十三屆「魏京生中國民主鬥士獎」征求提名

    【淇園漫步】兩位被遺忘的間諜:比安卡·譚和安東尼奧·里瓦Two Forgotten Spies: Bianca Tam and Antonio Riva

    上一個 下一個
  • 首頁
  • 關注熱點

    媒體人的良知與謊言(附楊繼繩書面答謝詞)

    北京五中全會「老虎成群」

    投資德國峰會斬逾2250億歐元承諾 梅爾茨以「可靠的」德國人形象招商

    歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

    21世紀的「法國大革命」

    上一個 下一個
  • 政經論壇

    北京五中全會「老虎成群」

    歐洲議會的堅決裁決:對中國種族滅絕與侵略政策的重創

    投資德國峰會斬逾2250億歐元承諾 梅爾茨以「可靠的」德國人形象招商

    MAGA文化戰爭正在自我毀滅 就讓共和黨自掘墳墓

    台灣是德國提升經濟韌性不可或缺的夥伴

    上一個 下一個
  • 人權觀察

    判它們一分鐘徒刑——光華社國殤紀念活動之超自然餘緒

    中國民主黨幹部學院將在倫敦啟動——首屆幹部培訓班同步舉行

    歐洲議會的堅決裁決:對中國種族滅絕與侵略政策的重創

    高瑜:丙午赤馬重陽節

    美國擬公開直播槍決爭議:民主法治與人權文明的倒退?

    上一個 下一個
  • 人文天下

    媒體人的良知與謊言(附楊繼繩書面答謝詞)

    老鬼新著《血的黎明》

    【老陳時評】假如老萬一直領導民運

    歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

    21世紀的「法國大革命」

    上一個 下一個
  • 歐洲風情

    【老陳時評】巴塞羅那的獨立紀念碑與西藏獨立運動

    再見,巴塞羅那!

    歐洲民主防護盾 為何與如何打造

    巴黎開業首日 Shein深陷輿論風暴

    展示向日葵的土地:艾未未深入「戰爭腹地」拍攝關於烏克蘭的電影

    上一個 下一個
  • 文學世界

    老鬼新著《血的黎明》

    2026年諾貝爾文學獎得主 安妮·卡森於2013年出版的《Red Doc>》

    台裔德國作家廖樂薇: 用文學展現台灣民主韌性

    Anne Carson wins Nobel prize in literature 2026安妮卡森榮獲2026年諾貝爾文學獎

    當文學遇上審查:高行健、劉曉波與莫言

    上一個 下一個
  • 視頻薈萃

    首屆劉曉波人權獎頒獎典禮

    聖尼古拉教堂:和平祈禱與自由精神的象徵

    《法蘭克福彙報》:歐洲向中國靠近

    CHINA UND WIR · Ein riskantes Spiel

    為信仰與理想奮鬥一生——劉曉波逝世 8 周年紀念會

    上一個 下一個
  • 專文
    • 田牧新著
    • 淇園漫步
    • 田牧筆談
    • 老陳時評
    • 胡平論政
    • 香江寄語
    • 北京觀察
    • 比爾曼自傳
    • 潤南文苑
    • 雪山下的火焰
    • 嚴家祺新著
    • 嚴家祺新著
    • 老魏論天下
    • 六四專欄
    • 追思萬潤南
    • 民運交流
    • 文革60週年
    • AI科技
    • 陽光法案
  • 古典音樂

    精選舒伯特鋼琴古典音樂Ⅱ

    約翰斯特勞斯「春之聲」圓舞曲

    維瓦地古典音樂精選

    孟德爾松古典音樂

    布拉姆斯古典音樂精選

    上一個 下一個
  • English

    A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

    中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era

    始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話

    魏京生基金會第二十三屆「魏京生中國民主鬥士獎」征求提名

    【淇園漫步】兩位被遺忘的間諜:比安卡·譚和安東尼奧·里瓦Two Forgotten Spies: Bianca Tam and Antonio Riva

    上一個 下一個
沒有結果
查看所有結果
歐洲之聲 Sino Euro Voices
沒有結果
查看所有結果
首頁 English

“Ineducable, Even in Reeducation Camp”

Tienchi martin-Liao文 /Tienchi martin-Liao
2020-09-06
在 English
“Ineducable, Even in Reeducation Camp”

Wang Xiaoning and Yu Ling in the early 1970s. Photo: courtesy of Tienchi Martin-Liao.

转换简体
分享到 Facebook分享到 Twitter分享到 Line分享到 WeChat

Writer and social critic Wang Xiaoning is released after ten years in prison

Yu Ling is a bit out of breath; the thermometer has almost climbed to 90 degrees Fahrenheit, totally unusual in Beijing. Maybe by end of the month it will be cooler, she thinks. And although she does not clean alone, as her son and daughter-in-law are with her, Yu is still tired. They have repainted the inside of the house, repaired the leak in the bathroom, and even replaced the old sink in the kitchen. Wang Xiaoning, her husband, will like it, she thinks. He should have a good impression of their home. After all, it has been ten years since he last saw it.

推薦新聞

A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

2026-10-12
中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era

中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era

2026-09-28

On August 31st Wang Xiaoning will be released from prison. In September 2002, Wang was arrested at his Beijing home in front of his wife and son. Born in 1950, Wang, the son of a minister, was raised in a family of high cadres. Had he behaved obediently, he could have had a good career enqueued among the “princelings.” Instead he chose a thornier path: Advocating for freedom and democracy in his country.

In the 1990s Wang studied engineering and worked as technician and businessman. In 1999 he created a website and started writing political commentary and analysis criticizing corruption and the government’s policies behind building the Three Gorges Dam. He also wrote a series of articles emphasizing the necessity of political reform in China.

His articles touched on sensitive topics like publication law, election regulations, and the corrupt military system in China. Wang even drafted a constitution. But his “anti-party and anti-socialism” writing alarmed the authorities, and his house was raided. Files and computers were confiscated. When Wang’s articles were published in the overseas online journal Democratic Forum the authority accused him of collaborating with foreign anti-China forces and arrested him. Because Wang disseminated his writing online and through his Yahoo account, the police pressured Yahoo to give Wang’s IP address to them. The court used this information as evidence of his crime and sentenced Wang to ten years in prison, accusing him of “inciting subversion of state power.”

China began the millennium with an image of iron and blood. Criminal law was amended in 1997, and the old terminology “counterrevolutionary propaganda crime” has been baptized with a new name—“inciting subversion of state power.” Nevertheless, the substance remains the same; it is still the state’s handy instrument to tame dissidents. Wang Xiaoning was one of the first severe cases of political persecution under the amended law, though there have been dozens of other cases of literary inquisition since the beginning of this century. If you break the will of the people and tread down their dignity, then they become a kind of dough that you can form as you like.

This is the secret of the Chinese Communist Party. With this tactic they have ruined generations of intellectuals. Yet there are still enough individuals made of special material who are irrepressible. In Chinese terms, these people would be called “ineducable” even when they are thrown into the “reeducation camp” and brainwashed for years. Wang Xiaoning is this kind of person. He has refused to show any regret or admit that he committed a crime. Had he bowed to the pressure his sentence would have been reduced to three years, but Wang stayed firm and served the full ten year sentence.

At the end of August, when he comes out of prison, we will see a thin, fragile man with grey hair whose eyes are still bright and sharp. His brave, slim wife, also in grey, will welcome him warmly. The pressure she has suffered over the past ten years has been no less than his. And while time does leave traces on their appearance, neither their spirit nor their will have been broken. They are higher then ever.

Updated on September 5, 2020:

 In 2007, Wang’ wife, Yu Ling, filed a lawsuit against Yahoo! for providing her husband’s IP and information to the authorities. The suit was settled out of court, Wang received compensation from Yahoo!

In recent years, Wang Xiaoning has been criticized for his pro-Mao writings. Li Nanyang, daughter of Mao’s private doctor, Li Zhisui, an aesthetics scholar, described Wang as “self expelled from the ranks of intellectuals and stepped into the rogue literati”. The change of Wang’s critical attitude to the CCP has indeed changed after ten years of imprisonment.

First published at Sampsoniaway.org on August 29, 2012.

標籤: cyber censorshipfreedom of expressionhuman rightspolitical prisonerTienchi Martin-LiaoWang XiaoningYahoo!Yu Ling
分享Tweet分享分享
上一篇文章

Woeser, a Lighthouse for Tibetans

下一篇文章

澳大利亞當局調查外國干涉高校

Tienchi martin-Liao

Tienchi martin-Liao

Tienchi Martin-Liao was the columnist of the Pittsburg literature online magazine SAMPSONIA WAY. She wrote for the FEARLESS INK column – Blind Chess from May 2012 till July 2018. The articles are reposted here, some of them are updated if necessary. Most of the topics and contents are still up to date, because in China the suppression on the intellectuals and dissidents is more severe then ever. There is no freedom of expression, no freedom of press, and people go to jail when they write things that offend the authority.

相關文章

A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing
English

A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

2026-10-12
中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era
English

中美關係正步入一個新時代The U.S. and China Are Entering a New Era

2026-09-28
始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話
English

始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話

2026-09-28
魏京生基金會第二十三屆「魏京生中國民主鬥士獎」征求提名
English

魏京生基金會第二十三屆「魏京生中國民主鬥士獎」征求提名

2026-09-28
【淇園漫步】兩位被遺忘的間諜:比安卡·譚和安東尼奧·里瓦Two Forgotten Spies: Bianca Tam and Antonio Riva
English

【淇園漫步】兩位被遺忘的間諜:比安卡·譚和安東尼奧·里瓦Two Forgotten Spies: Bianca Tam and Antonio Riva

2026-09-19
9·11事件真的改變了一切嗎?Did 9/11 Really Change Everything?
English

9·11事件真的改變了一切嗎?Did 9/11 Really Change Everything?

2026-09-11
下一篇文章
澳大利亞當局調查外國干涉高校

澳大利亞當局調查外國干涉高校

「王爺」講述蒙古少婦的故事——內蒙古地區蒙古語教學釀風潮

「王爺」講述蒙古少婦的故事——內蒙古地區蒙古語教學釀風潮

Hong Kong’s Waves of Protest Against “Brainwashing”

Hong Kong’s Waves of Protest Against “Brainwashing”

熱門文章

2026年諾貝爾文學獎得主 安妮·卡森於2013年出版的《Red Doc>》

2026年諾貝爾文學獎得主 安妮·卡森於2013年出版的《Red Doc>》

2026-10-17
七年後的回聲:從香港中聯辦到海牙,一首歌連起的兩代抗爭者

七年後的回聲:從香港中聯辦到海牙,一首歌連起的兩代抗爭者

2026-10-03
法國和平示威擴大為暴力騷亂 馬克宏歸咎極左派人士

法國和平示威擴大為暴力騷亂 馬克宏歸咎極左派人士

2026-10-19
美國擬公開直播槍決爭議:民主法治與人權文明的倒退?

美國擬公開直播槍決爭議:民主法治與人權文明的倒退?

2026-10-15
歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

歐盟正式發布改版後的《北極戰略》

2026-10-21
A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

A Beacon of Conscience for the Chinese Democracy Movement: A Commemorative Announcement on the First Anniversary of Mr. Wan Runnan’s Passing

2026-10-12
始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話

始於「去習」,重在「新生」——在中國國是會議舉辦有關習近平訪美及中國未來的新聞發布會上講話

2026-09-28
歐洲之聲

歐洲之聲網站根植於歐陸,創刊於庚子年新冠疫情席捲全球之際。數據化時代早已來臨,面對浩瀚的知識和信息海洋,太容易迷失方向。作為長年的媒體工作者,本網刊願為華語世界的讀者傳送平實可靠的資訊,也為追求民主、自由、人權的有識之士及愛好文藝的友朋提供寫作發文的平台。祈望這裡成為志同道合者共同耕耘的園地。

分類

  • AI科技
  • English
  • 人文天下
  • 人權觀察
  • 六四專欄
  • 北京觀察
  • 古典音樂
  • 嚴家祺新著
  • 圖博特
  • 墨爾本夜語
  • 專文
  • 政經論壇
  • 文學世界
  • 文革60週年
  • 未分類
  • 歐洲風情
  • 比爾曼自傳
  • 民運交流
  • 淇園漫步
  • 潤南文苑
  • 田牧新著
  • 田牧筆談
  • 老陳時評
  • 老魏論天下
  • 胡平論政
  • 視頻薈萃
  • 追思萬潤南
  • 關注熱點
  • 陽光法案
  • 雪山下的火焰
  • 香江寄語
  • 歐洲風情
【老陳時評】巴塞羅那的獨立紀念碑與西藏獨立運動

【老陳時評】巴塞羅那的獨立紀念碑與西藏獨立運動

2026-10-05
再見,巴塞羅那!

再見,巴塞羅那!

2026-08-05

適用電子郵件訂閱網站

輸入你的電子郵件地址訂閱網站的新文章,使用電子郵件接收新通知。

關注我們

沒有結果
查看所有結果
  • 首頁
  • 關注熱點
  • 政經論壇
  • 人權觀察
  • 人文天下
  • 歐洲風情
  • 文學世界
  • 視頻薈萃
  • 專文
    • 墨爾本夜語
    • 香江寄語
    • 胡平論政
    • 北京觀察
    • 潤南文苑
    • 淇園漫步
    • 老陳時評
    • 雪山下的火焰
  • English
  • 古典音樂
  • 田牧新著

© 2020 歐洲之聲 Sino Euro Voices.

歐洲之聲網站使用 cookie 為您提供更好的使用體驗, 請閱讀我們的 隱私權政策,通過使用表示您確認並同意我們的政策。